GTM Strategy
There are three main kinds of help you can hire for Jobs-to-be-Done and customer research. Here’s what to ask before you hire anyone.
By Shannon Kearns, published 2026-11-07, 10 min read.
You can hire a product marketing consultant who runs customer research, or a specialist Jobs-to-be-Done consultancy. Which one is right depends on the decision you need to make. If you want to understand why people choose your product and turn that into positioning and messaging, look for someone who interviews recent customers about what they actually did, and who stays involved until the findings change what your team says.
Before shopping for a method or vendor, be clear about the decision the research needs to support.
If you're not sure what kind of research you need, start with a product marketing consultant who has a strong research background. They can help you work out which research will give you the evidence you need to make your decisions.
Jobs-to-be-Done is a way of understanding customers by the progress they're trying to make in a specific situation, instead of only by who they are. Clayton Christensen and his co-authors laid it out in Harvard Business Review: people "hire" a product to get a job done, and they "fire" whatever they were using before when it stops working for them.
That changes who you think your competitors are. Take a made-up example: a small agency owner who buys invoicing software. They didn't wake up wanting invoicing software. They wanted to stop chasing late payments by email at the end of every month. Their real alternatives were a spreadsheet, a bookkeeper, and doing nothing for one more month. Those are the options your positioning has to beat.
There are two well-known approaches to JTBD research (they aren't the only ones). One, associated with Bob Moesta and The Re-Wired Group, interviews recent customers to reconstruct how they made a decision. The other, Outcome-Driven Innovation from Strategyn, identifies the outcomes customers use to judge a job, then ranks those outcomes with large-scale survey research. You'll see both again when we get to who to hire.
JTBD interviews answer one kind of question: why people choose a product and what they left behind. Plenty of decisions need a different method, and a good practitioner will tell you when you're asking the wrong one.
| Method | Use it when you need to know | What you learn | Limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| JTBD interviews | Why people choose a product and what they switched from | The situations, alternatives and worries behind a real decision | A small sample shows what happens, not how often |
| Win/loss interviews | Why deals close or fall through | What tipped recent sales decisions | You need access to buyers who said no |
| Usability testing | Whether people can use the product | Where people get stuck | Says little about why they bought |
| Surveys | How common a pattern is | How many people share it, and in which segments | Only as good as the questions, which usually come from interviews first |
| Churn research | Why people stop using the product | Reasons for leaving and gaps after adoption | Different people and different questions from adoption research |
| Pricing research | What people will pay and how they compare offers | How price and packaging change the decision | What people say they'd pay is unreliable on its own |
Teams often combine these. A common order is interviews first, to find the patterns, then a survey to check how widespread they are. Nielsen Norman Group makes the same point about interviews in general: they're good for understanding motivations and experiences, and weak for predicting what people will do in the future.
When the question is "why do people choose us," JTBD interviews give you answers in your customers' own words, which is exactly what positioning and messaging should be built from.
What you get:
What you don't get: proof of how common any of this is. A set of interviews tells you what happens and why. People's memories of a decision are also imperfect, so you look for patterns across interviews instead of building a headline on one quote. JTBD interviews also don't replace churn research, usability testing, or pricing research.
Interview people who recently started using the product, while the decision is still fresh. That's how I run this work. I set eligibility from the research question before recruiting anyone, for example people who started in a recent window, made or influenced the purchase, and used something else before.
Eligibility follows the research question. Long-time customers and people who've canceled can still fit an adoption study if they made the decision recently enough to reconstruct it, and then you ask them the same adoption questions. If the question is why people leave, that's a separate study with its own questions, so I only add that scope when the research question calls for it.
In the interview itself, I reconstruct the actual decision: what they used before, the timeline, what pushed them to change, and what job they hired the product to do. The activity often existed before the product did. In the invoicing example, your customer was sending invoices long before they found your software, so the useful question is why they wanted a different way of doing it.
Questions like these keep the conversation on real events (shown here for the invoicing example):
Many practitioners map the answers to a decision timeline (first thought, looking around, actively comparing, deciding, first use) and to four forces: the push of the current situation, the pull of the new solution, anxiety about the new solution, and the habit of the present way. Only record a force if the person actually described it.
How many interviews? There's no universal number. Plan it from the segments you need to cover, how complicated the decision is, and the quality of what you're hearing, along with how much time and recruiting access you have.
A few basics apply to any customer interview. Tell people what the interview is for, how it's recorded, who can see the notes, and how long they're kept. Get permission to record. Ask separately before you use anything from an interview publicly, because removing a name isn't the same as permission.
After each eligible interview, I write the notes and a separate JTBD overview. If someone turns out not to fit the criteria, I mark the interview excluded and leave it out of the synthesis.
A good general practice from there is to compare across interviews, keep the cases that contradict each other, and report what the study covered against the original plan.
Most of these come down to asking for opinions instead of history, or stopping before the findings get used.
The person hiring is usually a founder, head of product, or product marketer who has a positioning, messaging, or product decision coming up and no clear evidence on why customers choose them.
It tends to show up as one of these:
These three options illustrate different kinds of help. Choose by the question you're trying to answer and what you need once the research is done.
A product marketing consultant who runs customer research. This fits when you want the research and the translation into positioning, messaging, and launch work from the same person. That's what I do at More Than Said. Customer & Market Research runs about two months, from $10,000, and covers the competitive landscape, customer and buyer research, and stakeholder interviews, delivered as a state-of-the-state. The JTBD part is interview-based, focused on recent adopters, and carried into positioning and messaging.
An interview-based JTBD consultancy. The Re-Wired Group, founded by Bob Moesta, offers consumer behavior consulting using JTBD, cross-functional alignment, product development consulting, and coaching for teams. This fits when you want to work with the people most associated with the interview approach, or you want your own team trained in it.
An outcome-based JTBD consultancy. Strategyn runs Outcome-Driven Innovation. It defines the market around a job, uncovers the outcomes customers use to judge it, then ranks those outcomes with quantitative research and segments the market by which ones are unmet. This fits larger product and innovation programs that want statistical prioritization behind their roadmap.
| Option | Best fit | What you're buying |
|---|---|---|
| Product marketing consultant (e.g. More Than Said) | You need research turned into positioning, messaging, and launch work | Interviews, synthesis, and the translation into what your team says |
| Interview-based JTBD firm (e.g. The Re-Wired Group) | You want the interview method, or your team trained in it | JTBD projects and coaching |
| Outcome-based JTBD firm (e.g. Strategyn) | You need quantitative prioritization of customer needs | Outcome discovery, survey research, and segmentation |
Look for someone who interviews about real past decisions, gets up to speed on your product fast, stays neutral, and gets your team to act on the findings. Ask each of these in the first call:
Deliverables depend on the research question and the approach. For an interview-based study aimed at positioning and messaging, expect a research plan and screener, notes from each interview, a JTBD summary per interview, a synthesis across interviews that shows how strong each finding is, and positioning or messaging hypotheses with a plan to test them. An Outcome-Driven Innovation program produces different outputs, so ask each provider what you'll get. If the work ends at a slide deck, ask who is going to carry it into your website copy and sales conversations.
A regular customer interview often asks for feedback on the product. A JTBD interview reconstructs one real decision: what the person used before, what pushed them to look, what nearly stopped them, and why they committed when they did.
There's no fixed number. Plan from the segments you need to cover, how complicated the decision is, and the quality of what you're hearing, along with your time and recruiting access.
It depends on the research question. If they adopted recently enough to reconstruct that decision, they can be part of an adoption study, asked the same adoption questions. If you want to know why people leave, that's a separate study with its own questions.
The Re-Wired approach is qualitative: interviews that reconstruct how recent customers made a decision. Outcome-Driven Innovation starts with qualitative discovery of the outcomes customers care about, then ranks them with large-scale survey research.
Yes, if someone can interview without leading, has time to synthesize properly, and the team will act on what comes out. Outside help is worth it when you're too close to the product, nobody has done this kind of interviewing before, or you need the findings turned into positioning and messaging.
My Customer & Market Research engagement starts at $10,000 and runs about two months. Other firms price differently, so ask each one for a scoped quote.
Read more articles, explore services and pricing, or take the free Go-to-Market Readiness Assessment.